August 2020
M T W T F S S
« Jul    
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31  
Tags
AIIB ASEAN ASEAN (R) ASEAN-ISIS Asia Beijing Big Tech CH: Hong Kong Country (R): Indonesia Country (R): Malaysia Country (R): Myanmar Country (R): Singapore Country: ASEAN Country: Australia Country: Cambodia Country: China Country: Germany Country: India Country: Indonesia Country: Japan Country: Laos Country: Malaysia Country: Myanmar Country: North Korea Country: Philippines Country: Qatar Country: Russia Country: Singapore Country: South Korea Country: Taiwan Country: Thailand Country: UK Country: United States Country: US Country: USA Country: Vietnam DE: 5G DE: Data privacy DE: Data security DE: e-Payments DE: Facebook Elections: Indonesia 2019 Elections: Thailand 2019 ESG: Climate Change ESG: Diversity ESG: Energy ESG: Green Finance ESG: Green Growth ESG: Haze ESG: Human Rights ESG: Modern Slavery ESG: Peatland ESG: Riau ESG: RSPO ESG: Smallholders ESG: Sustainability ESG: Sustainable/Green Infrastructure ESG: Workers Rights European Union Event: SDSWR Events: AAF Fukushima G20 Global Citizens Singapore Google Indonesia: Jokowi Institute: ERIA Institute: SIIA JP: Abenomics Leaders: Kim Jong Un Leaders: Lee Hsien Loong Megatrends: Digitisation Megatrends: Populism MM: Aung San Suu Kyi MM: NLD MM: Rakhine State MY: Anwar Ibrahim MY: GE14 MY: Mahathir Mohamad MY: Najib Razak Nicholas Fang Oh Ei Sun Region: Africa Region: Latin America Region: Middle East Reports Security: South China Sea Security: Terrorism SG: Lee Kuan Yew SG: SG Secure SG: Smart Nation SG: Society Simon Tay Sustainable infrastructure TH: Protests Topic (R): Belt and Road Topic (R): Business Topic (R): Digitisation Topic (R): Economy Topic (R): Green Finance Topic (R): Haze Topic (R): Infrastructure Topic (R): Palm Oil Topic (R): Peatland Topic (R): Smallholders Topic (R): Sustainability Topic: Anti-Globalisation Topic: Belt and Road Topic: Business Topic: Coronavirus Topic: COVID-19 Topic: Development Topic: Digital Economy Topic: Digitisation Topic: E-Commerce Topic: Economics Topic: Economy Topic: Elections Topic: Environment Topic: ESG Topic: Finance Topic: Global Citizens Topic: Globalisation Topic: Human Trafficking Topic: Indo-Pacific Topic: Infrastructure Topic: Investment Topic: Labour Topic: Nuclear Topic: Palm Oil Topic: Race Topic: Regional Integration Topic: Religion Topic: Security Topic: Singapore-Malaysia Relations Topic: Small States Topic: Trade Trade: AEC Trade: FTA Trade: FTAAP Trade: RCEP Trade: TPP Trade: War Trends (Digital): Cybersecurity UK: Brexit United States US: Obama US: Trump US: Trump WEF

Poor human trafficking records and implications for ASEAN

tip-report-2014-600

01 Jul Poor human trafficking records and implications for ASEAN

In June, the US State Department released its annual Trafficking in Persons (TIP) Report, which ranks countries based on their efforts to combat modern slavery. The report did not put any countries of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) at Tier 1, the rank that acknowledges compliance with minimum standards of fighting human trafficking. What’s more, Malaysia and Thailand were downgraded to Tier 3, the worst possible ranking.

This demotion to Tier 3, a rank that indicates no progress in terms of fighting human trafficking, puts Malaysia and Thailand in the same category as Iran, North Korea and Syria. The TIP report highlighted Thailand and Malaysia’s thriving sex trade, and also focused on forced labour in the agricultural, fishing, domestic work, and textile industries. Additionally, US Ambassador to the Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, Luis CdeBaca, stated that “widespread official complicity in human trafficking” was hindering Thailand’s progress.

A Tier 3 ranking can become grounds for economic sanctions, including blocking various types of aid, or withdrawal of US support for loans from the World Bank or the International Monetary Fund. Unsurprisingly, Thailand has gone on the defensive. Acting Foreign Minister Sihasak Phuangketkeow stated the government’s disappointment and disagreement with the downgrade, saying that “suppressing human trafficking” is the government’s “highest priority.” Similarly, Malaysia’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs declared “serious” commitment to combating human trafficking, and accused the US of using “flawed” and “inaccurate” information in its report.

Singapore, which has remained at Tier 2 for the past three years, has also urged the US to “adopt a more objective methodology” to ensure that “a consistent, transparent and measurable standard” is applied fairly to all countries.

ASEAN nations may reject the TIP report findings, but their less than favourable rankings are not shocking. In fact, the low rankings fit within a larger trend of human rights violations in the region. While the 2008 ASEAN Charter refers to protecting human rights and promoting social justice, Article 1 emphasises ASEAN’s commitment to non-interference and national sovereignty. Consequently, tensions and roadblocks arise when ASEAN nations deem human rights issues purely domestic affairs, which are not subject to ASEAN’s supra-national oversight.

In light of mounting pressure to achieve the ASEAN Economic Community in 2015, it is perhaps wise for ASEAN to hold off on addressing sensitive human rights issues. ASEAN should, however, keep in mind that human rights violations have the potential to escalate into destabilising regional conflicts and create animosity between its members. It is imperative therefore, that ASEAN becomes more united, forward-looking, and proactive when handling human rights issues. This will encourage the timely building of ASEAN’s Social-Cultural Pillar as part of the ASEAN Vision 2020, and allow ASEAN to have a greater role in regional and global affairs.

Sources:

Thailand deeply disappointed with downgrading in US human trafficking report
 [Straits Times, 21 Jun 2014] (Requires login)

Statement on the US State Department Trafficking in Persons Report 2014 —Ministry of Foreign Affairs (Malaysia) [Malay Mail Online (Malaysia MFA), 22 Jun 2014]

Singapore inter-agency taskforce responds to US report on human trafficking
 [TODAY, 21 Jun 2014]

Growing an ASEAN Voice?: A Common Platform in Global and Regional Governance by Simon Tay, ERIA Discussion Paper 2013-16

ASEAN Charter 

Photo Credit: US State Department